Understanding Probable Cause Court in Rowan County, North Carolina

When someone faces a criminal charge for a felony in Rowan County, one of the first major steps is the probable cause hearing. This stage is often misunderstood, yet it plays a crucial role in deciding whether a felony case will move forward to Superior Court.

---

What is a Probable Cause Hearing

A probable cause hearing is an early proceeding in District Court. The judge’s job is to decide whether there is enough evidence to justify continuing prosecution of a felony-level charge, or a related misdemeanor.

This is not a trial. The question is not whether the person is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Instead, the judge asks whether there is “probable cause” to believe a crime occurred and that the defendant likely committed it.

The hearing serves as a safeguard against unjustified prosecutions. It ensures that serious charges are supported by some factual basis before being sent to Superior Court.

---

Jurisdiction and Timing in Rowan County

In Rowan County, which is part of Prosecutorial District 27, felony cases begin in District Court. After a person’s first appearance, the court must schedule a probable cause hearing within fifteen working days. The defense and prosecutor can agree to hold it sooner if both sides are ready.

If no District Court session is available within that time, the case will appear on the next available calendar. These timelines come directly from state law and are reflected in the North Carolina Prosecution Manual. The timeline is designed to move cases forward efficiently while giving both sides a fair chance to prepare.

---

How Probable Cause Court Works in Practice

While North Carolina law provides for “true” probable cause hearings, they are rarely conducted in Rowan County. What most people refer to as “PC Court” serves a different function in practice.

On a typical PC Court day, the docket often includes bond hearings, pleas to Class H and I felonies, pleas to misdemeanors, and continuances requested by the State. These continuances allow prosecutors additional time to secure an indictment from a grand jury so the case can move to Superior Court. Additionally cases are continued if discovery (the evidence against you) has not yet been made available.

In other words, the courtroom still carries the “probable cause” label, but the vast majority of cases never reach a full evidentiary hearing on probable cause. Instead, the session operates as a key management stage for the county’s felony caseload.

---

What Happens During a True Probable Cause Hearing

When a true probable cause hearing does occur, the process is straightforward:

1. The State presents its evidence. This may include testimony from officers, written statements, or physical exhibits.

2. The judge focuses on two questions:

   • Is there probable cause to believe the alleged offense occurred?

   • Is there probable cause to believe the defendant committed it?

3. The defense can cross-examine witnesses and point out gaps or inconsistencies in the State’s case.

4. The defense does not present its full case. This stage is about testing whether the State’s evidence clears the initial threshold, not proving innocence.

---

Possible Outcomes

At the conclusion of the probable cause hearing, the judge in Rowan County must choose one of three outcomes:

1. Probable cause found for the charged felony. The case is sent to Superior Court for prosecution.

2. No probable cause for the felony, but probable cause for a lesser misdemeanor. The judge can schedule the misdemeanor for trial in District Court, allow a plea to the lesser offense, or hold the trial immediately if both sides agree.

3. No probable cause for any offense. The case is dismissed. However, the prosecutor may still seek an indictment later because jeopardy does not attach at this stage.

---

Why the Hearing Matters for Defense Strategy

PC Court is more than a procedural stop on the calendar. It’s a chance to test how the State plans to build its case and to learn what evidence will matter most later.

A probable cause hearing gives the defense an early look at the State’s evidence, revealing potential weaknesses or inconsistencies. A strong challenge at this stage can sometimes result in dismissal before the case reaches Superior Court.

Even when the hearing results in a finding of probable cause, it helps shape the next steps. The defense gains valuable insight into which witnesses and facts the State is relying on, which guides motion practice, discovery requests, and trial strategy.

Defense lawyers who take PC Court seriously gain a strategic edge. Preparation here often sets the tone for the rest of the case.

---

Practical Tips for Handling the Hearing in Rowan County PC Court

• File a request for the hearing promptly. The right can be waived if not exercised in time.

• Review all available discovery, including reports and witness statements.

• Prepare focused cross-examination to highlight missing or unreliable evidence.

• Identify potential suppression issues, such as an unlawful search or arrest.

• Move to dismiss the case if the State’s evidence falls short.

• If the case moves to Superior Court, pivot quickly to the next phase of defense planning.

---

Key Takeaways for Defense Lawyers

• The probable cause hearing serves as the gateway from District Court to Superior Court for felony cases.

• In Rowan County, true probable cause hearings are uncommon, but PC Court remains a critical setting for case management, bond arguments, and plea negotiations.

• The standard is lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt but still meaningful.

• A well-prepared defense can use this stage to test the State’s case, preserve issues, and build leverage for later negotiations or motions.

• In Rowan County, success often comes down to preparation, focus, and precision.

---

Built to Defend. Trained to Win.
If you or someone you know has a felony case in Rowan County, contact Stowe Law Firm to learn how we can help protect your rights and guide you through every stage of the process.